Best Pizza in Thomasville

Q: Where are you located?

We are located in Thomasville, NC at 106 W Main St

A Local Spot for Fresh Italian Meals in Thomasville

Order online

Featured

View menu

Welcome to Elizabeth’s Pizza #1

Elizabeth's Pizza #1 is a friendly spot in Thomasville, NC serving fresh Italian-American food made every day for dine-in, takeout, delivery, catering, and reservations, where guests of all ages can enjoy a simple and relaxed meal in a warm setting with helpful staff ready to serve you.

Get Directions

Fresh Italian-American Favorites

At Elizabeth's Pizza #1, we serve hand-tossed New York–style pizza, pasta dishes like spaghetti, lasagna, baked ziti, chicken alfredo, and seafood pasta, plus calzones, strombolis, subs, salads, and kid meals, all made fresh daily with simple ingredients and steady quality you can trust.

Explore Our Menu

Host Your Next Gathering in Our Private Room

Our private space offers a warm, intimate setting perfect for birthdays, showers, corporate meetings, or any occasion worth celebrating. With comfortable seating for up to 40 guests, it's the ideal spot to gather your favorite people without the crowd. Reserve the Room · Call Us: (336) 476-7444

Easy Ordering Options

Elizabeth's Pizza #1 makes ordering simple with dine-in, takeout, delivery, catering, and reservations so you can enjoy your meal your way whether you are at home, at work, or dining in with family and friends.

Order Now

A Look at Our Fresh Italian Favorites

Take a look at what we serve at Elizabeth's Pizza #1 and see the fresh meals we prepare every day. Each dish is made with care and served in portions made for sharing, quick meals, or family dining.

Catering Made Easy for Any Occasion

Elizabeth's Pizza #1 offers catering for meetings, parties, school events, family gatherings, and special occasions, with fresh Italian-American food made in large portions so your group can enjoy pizza, pasta, subs, salads, and more without the stress of cooking, all prepared fresh with the same care as our in-store meals and ready for pickup or delivery to make planning simple and convenient.

Order Catering

Private Dining & Reservations

Elizabeth's Pizza #1 offers reservations for guests who want a more comfortable and private dining experience, perfect for family celebrations, small parties, business meals, or group gatherings, with a private space where you can enjoy fresh Italian-American dishes in a relaxed setting while our team takes care of everything so you can focus on your time together.

Reserve Now

Family-Owned, Local & Ready to Serve

Elizabeth's Pizza #1 is a family-owned restaurant focused on fresh, made-from-scratch food like hand-made dough and small-batch sauces, giving every dish a steady, homestyle taste that reflects care, tradition, and strong local roots, and we welcome you to visit us at 106 W Main St, Thomasville, NC where we serve lunch and dinner in a relaxed, casual setting made for everyday dining.

PERFECT PLACE TO BE TAKEN TO FOR MY EARLY BIRTHDAY MEAL!! Food phenomenal! Service the best atmosphere perfect!! Our server Michelle was super friendly with a warm and welcoming smile very nice and personable personality! Annalise came over to ensure we got proper service she was super sweet too! This place is over an hour away from my home but it has now been added to my TOP 3 list and I will be returning at least once a month! Did I mention they have the BEST ARNOLD PALMER I have ever had!! The food was so good we even ordered dinner to go! I had the chicken parmigiana (to die for) you can taste the authenticity!! With a Cesar salad on the side my God the freshness was easy to see!! I ordered a Tiramisu and cheesesteak supreme w/jalapeno to go! I can’t wait to eat it tonight!!

Yolanda B.

Hands down some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. The crust is perfect, the toppings are always fresh, and every slice is packed with flavor. Beyond the pizza, everything else I’ve tried has been phenomenal—clearly made with care and consistency. You can tell they take pride in their food. This place has become a go-to for me, and it never disappoints. Highly recommend to anyone looking for amazing pizza and top-notch quality across the menu.

Hayley O.

This Place Is Delizioso, Squisito and Fenomenale!!! The Food Is Amazing And The Staff There Are Very Friendly!! We Love The Atmosphere!! Sidney Was Very Attentive And Tony The Chef Was Absolutely Awesome!!! I Can't Give Enough Praise About This Place!!! I'm From NY And This Pizza Rivals The Pizza I Get From Up There. All The Food We've Gotten From There Has Been Spot On!!! This Is Our Second Time Here And We're Now Regulars. We Absolutely LOVE This Place!!! I Highly Recommend Going Here If You Want REAL Authentic Italian Pizza, Pasta And Subs!!! The Dessert Was Absolutely Delicious!! Chef Specialty!! Just Wow!!!

Jason B.

This food was slap yo mama delicious. The authenticity of it makes me want to go to Italy to double check. The marina sauce was the richest I have ever had. The service was great and I will travel the extra 35 miles off my normal route for this experience again.

Adrian S.

Featuring

Dine-In

Takeout

Delivery

Catering

Reservations

Outdoor Seating

Our Story: Fresh Italian Roots in Thomasville

Elizabeth's Pizza #1 is under new management with a team rooted in Naples traditions, focused on serving fresh and simple Italian-American food made daily for the Thomasville community; our menu includes New York–style pizza, pasta dishes, calzones, strombolis, subs, salads, and more, all prepared fresh with homemade sauces and hand-made dough using simple methods and quality ingredients, making every meal consistent and filling for families and guests any day of the week, while we continue to focus on friendly service, steady quality, and a welcoming experience for dine-in, takeout, delivery, and catering at our location on 106 W Main St, Thomasville, NC 27360.